When studying about 17th-century Plymouth or visiting Plimoth Plantation, students will encounter two cultures that are probably quite unfamiliar to them. Teachers can help students by preparing them to approach the colonists and native Wampanoag with curiosity and an open mind.
But students can't begin to move beyond a surface impression
of these or other cultures, until they accept the equality and
worth of people who may be very different from themselves. People
from other cultures, both past and present, are not just "us in
funny clothes." A culture is a distinct group bound by shared
customs, languages, arts and behaviors.
The challenge for educators is to help students recognize their
own cultural biases and to avoid judging others by their own standards.
It can be especially challenging to respect cultures of the past,
since we tend to feel superior to "primitive" people.
Sensitivity is acting with respect. When encountering other cultures,
it is our responsibility to be polite and respectful as we get
to know the people of that culture. While we can endeavor to learn
and have empathy for cultures other than our own, we can never
know what it is like to be them. It is considered disrespectful
by the Wampanoag to dress as they do or to re-create their ceremonial
activities. Doing so implies a simplistic and one-dimensional
view of what makes up the Wampanoag culture.
Once students learn to be respectful, they can begin to identify
and value perspectives other than their own. By better understanding
the people of 17th-century Patuxet and Plymouth, students can
begin to see how each group's cultural ways determined their actions
and, ultimately, the course of history in New England. This more
thoughtful approach will help students avoid the stereotypes and
superficial judgements which could lead to insensitive and hurtful
behavior on Plimoth Plantation's sites.
When studying Plymouth Colony in the classroom or preparing for a field trip, we urge you not to study only the "Pilgrims." The story of the English colonists and the Wampanoag in the 17th century involves the oppression of one group of people by another. Native People today are still feeling the impact of this imposition. By considering only the struggles and courage of the colonists, students may not realize the devastating effect colonization had on the Wampanoag.
Plimoth Plantation strives to present the events of 17th-century
Plymouth from many perspectives - not just the Wampanoag and colonists'
perspectives, but those of individuals within these groups. In
doing so, we hope museum visitors can begin to see why people
of the past made the decisions they did. Rather than merely judging
the choices made by the colonists or Wampanoag as right or wrong,
we hope visitors will try to understand why the decisions were
made.
Before students can begin to appreciate why the colonists and
Wampanoag might have thought and acted as they did, they need
to confront the assumptions and misinformation that have influenced
our view of these two cultures. They need to realize, for instance,
that the English colonists did not wear buckles on their shoes
and hats and that they did not believe in religious toleration.
They should also recognize the inappropriateness of stereotyping
Native People by war whoops or by considering them super-human
or sub-human.
pilgrim first thanksgiving american history plymouth rock mayflower